One of the books I read during my recent illness was Notable American Women, a novel by Ben Marcus from 2002. I had read the book previously at least a decade ago, but remembered little of it other than the slipperiness of Marcus' writing, which makes heavy use of figurative language that leaves you questioning what's really going on in the story. Here's one example:
This man had a failure in his neck five times, which resulted in immobility of the torso and head and led to the use of an old foul-smelling neck brace once prescribed for him when these body failures were more frequent, then later used as a language diaper when uncontrollable speech was a symptom, a pillowy brace, shaped like a snake, that was saturated in all of his unwanted words, stinking of a version of himself he wasn't able to share with the world, wrapped around his neck, a towel for his secrets.
And another:
Should the standard Ohio Motion Detection Device™, as worn by a Jane Dark representative, register natural movement of any sort on my person, or a wobbling palsy arising from my body, as with nervous hands, whether through tethers, leashes, or strings that snap taut if I so much as move, or a sonar device that alerts a Jane Dark Representative, who might occupy an observation booth, of motion occurring from my person, this contract shall become void and may not again be undertaken. Nor might any future accidental paralysis of mine, or frozen body condition that I may adopt, whether through enforced stillness, straightjacketing, coffin incarceration, or any other unnamed method of stillness, including my apparent demise, even if it proves a real demise, complete with eulogy, burial, and headstone, or a real demise that lacks these rituals, but still occurs, such as my body flung from a vehicle and come to rest in a ditch, where it is never discovered, but is still technically in a state of demise, be indicative of a successful promise of stillness, but instead shall signify an aberrant or natural pause in my motion akin to a stop-time event in a bird migration, such as birds pausing midair to perform a shadow function on the land below — which in some cases is a system of messaging for those women equipped to read it — or some other unsanctioned event resulting in stillness, such as a personal gridlock, a crisis in motion, or a Syrup Action.
Reading Marcus is a bit like exploring a dream as you get a sense of wrongness about everything he writes, with words flipped on their sides to create new meaning. You can follow the narrative, but you need to re-read sections repeatedly as the text slips through your mind because it lacks familiar hooks — or rather because the familiar has been commandeered for new, unexpected uses.
Which led me to wondering which game experiences, if any, you might classify as being in a similar category of wrongness. You understand the rules for how to play, yet your intuition and actions feel like mistakes, or the flow of the game seems counterintuitive to what you expect.
Two games came to mind for me: Wilko Manz's Fifth Avenue from 2004 and Franz-Benno Delonge and Thomas Ewert's Container from 2007.

Fifth Avenue was part of alea's well-loved "big box" series, but the previous title — 2003's Mammoth Hunters — had seemed like a letdown following games like The Princes of Florence, The Traders of Genoa, and Puerto Rico, and Fifth Avenue seemed even more of a miss as players could take actions early on that essentially crashed out the game. You'd look at the scoretrack that tops out at 80 and say, "Why was our winning score 11?!" But rather than tackle the game again, many wrote it off and moved on. (I've played eight times and really dig its offbeat feel, but it hasn't hit the table in a long time, so it's one to dig out of the storage unit soon.)
Container was also counter-intuitive as you produced goods that you couldn't buy, placed goods in your warehouse that you couldn't ship, and ship goods to an island that you must sell to others because you can't keep them for yourself. Also, you can get yourself into a loan spiral that will doom your chances for progress.
Which games would you add to this category of avant-garde designs that feel like you're playing them wrong?
Want more articles like this?
Get Board Game Beat’s free posts by email — original reporting, designer interviews, and industry news, with no tracking and no spam.